2025 San Francisco Giants Season Thread

Originally posted by DaManRathman:
How many runs is Ramos gonna give up in LF this season? Dude is rough out there.

Dude has a puss arm

Originally posted by Rubberneck36:

Originally posted by DaManRathman:
How many runs is Ramos gonna give up in LF this season? Dude is rough out there.

Dude has a puss arm

Ramos has a good arm. Scouts rate it at 60 which is very good. It's his decision making that can be a problem. Knowing where to throw.

Switch hicks and birdsongs roles an dfa Lamonte an put Eldridge at first

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:
Switch hicks and birdsongs roles an dfa Lamonte an put Eldridge at first

Eldridge has played one game after coming off the IR. He still doesn't kniw how to ply first base well enough. His hitting progress would suffer as well since there is usually a huge drop when players reach the big league livel. Let the guy learn to play at least well enough that he won't be costing games with errors at first.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Eldridge has played one game after coming off the IR. He still doesn't kniw how to ply first base well enough. His hitting progress would suffer as well since there is usually a huge drop when players reach the big league livel. Let the guy learn to play at least well enough that he won't be costing games with errors at first.

Well, then maybe have Eldridge DH and play Flores at first. Eldridge can't do any worse than LWJ, no matter what he does. So let him learn big league on the fly.

come on walker!!!!

geeez, I've never seen walker have two bad outings in a row

doval with the save, must be smelling the opportunity to get the closer job back

Originally posted by FaTaL:
doval with the save, must be smelling the opportunity to get the closer job back

4 more until number 100.

That Anaheim blown save broke Walker. Bro has the yips at the moment.

Originally posted by tl57:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Eldridge has played one game after coming off the IR. He still doesn't kniw how to ply first base well enough. His hitting progress would suffer as well since there is usually a huge drop when players reach the big league livel. Let the guy learn to play at least well enough that he won't be costing games with errors at first.

Well, then maybe have Eldridge DH and play Flores at first. Eldridge can't do any worse than LWJ, no matter what he does. So let him learn big league on the fly.

You're missing the point. He can't learn to play first base if he's a DH and they want him to be the everyday first baseman. There's also no guarantee that he can hit big league pitching at this point. Let's not rush him and have to end up sending him back down. He's still only 20. He's the best LH hitting prospect they've had in years so they can't afford to mess him up.

Posey is on KNBR as I type this. He just said Eldrige is a long ways away from the big leagues and needs a lot of work on defense and polishing his hitting.

LWJ hitting .098

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
You're missing the point. He can't learn to play first base if he's a DH and they want him to be the everyday first baseman. There's also no guarantee that he can hit big league pitching at this point. Let's not rush him and have to end up sending him back down. He's still only 20. He's the best LH hitting prospect they've had in years so they can't afford to mess him up.

Posey is on KNBR as I type this. He just said Eldrige is a long ways away from the big leagues and needs a lot of work on defense and polishing his hitting.

yes. i've heard posey also before the season. he says in an ideal type situation eldridge is down all year in the minors. dude is 20 y/o

Harper was 19 when called up. Not saying Eldridge should be called up, I am just saying its about how he performs, not how old he is.

Originally posted by Rubberneck36:
Harper was 19 when called up. Not saying Eldridge should be called up, I am just saying its about how he performs, not how old he is.

Yep. I am so tired of hearing people claim that the way we have managed some of our prospects has "ruined them." I am so tired of hearing "we cant rush a prospect, because we will 'ruin.'"

If a player is good, he is going to be good. This isnt the NFL where you can David Carr a QB because of an offensive line.