Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
Cconsidering where he was picked I do think he will be a bust. At best I think you are looking at a .240 hitter with 20 homers. I would say a good comparison is Mike Zunino with a bit less power.
Seriously hope I'm wrong and Joey gets it going but I think there are too many holes in that swing
I thought he was last year which is why I was OK if they traded him. I think he's done a pretty good job of calling a game when he plays. Much better than I thought he would. He doesn't block balls very well. Early on he threw a runner out and I thought made some improvements, but inconsistencies popped up the other day and he sailed one. Bad form.
At the plate he doesn't seem to adjust and doesn't seem to hit breaking balls well. I think your assessment of his potential is correct.
Overall, if the giants aren't better than they are last year its because of the lack of production at two spots - our two catchers and our DH/extra OFer spots. With the pitching staff, I think they are poised to compete better in the playoffs than last year. But I'm worried we have some almost automatic outs/inning killers in those two spots in the lineup.